Purebred vs. Mixed Breed Puppies: Pros and Cons


We love all dogs, whether mutts or purebreds, but sometimes, when considering adding a new puppy to your home, you may have difficulty deciding between a purebred and a mixed-breed puppy. 

Many would say that a mixed breed dog from a shelter works for most homes; nonetheless, even with a DNA testing kit to check a mixed breed’s ancestry, a cheek swab may not accurately predict the percentage of the breed that will manifest itself behind a mixed breed.

Whether you’re a purebred or mixed-breed aficionado, we can help you choose a breed or mix breed. Sometimes called a hybrid or crossbreed, mixed breeds can combine numerous breeds, resulting in a mish-mash of characteristics that make each dog very special.

When considering a purebred or mixed-breed puppy, each option has advantages and drawbacks, and understanding these factors is essential in making an informed choice. 

Whether it’s the playful energy of a Labrador mix, the intelligence of a Border Collie mix, or the affectionate nature of a Terrier mix, each mixed breed dog brings its charm and individuality to the table, enriching the lives of those fortunate enough to welcome them into their homes. Here’s the takeaway:

Mixed Breed Dogs



Whether you purchase a purebred or mixed breed, you can get a healthy puppy on whichever route you choose. All dogs are individuals; all breeds were bred for specific tasks, and dogs from particular breeds will have similar personality traits. If you purchase or adopt a mixed breed, chances are you won’t know what your puppy will look like as an adult.

Mixed breed dogs, often called “mutts,” offer many benefits, making them a popular choice for dog lovers. “The price of a mixed breed may be higher, depending on whether particular breeds were intentionally bred to produce a new breed (such as Puggles – Pug+Beagle),” says PetMD.

PetMD also says, “A mixed-breed puppy often has the advantage of having a much lower chance of being born with inherited congenital diseases, since the mating process naturally leaves out the defective genes. This is a general truism.”

Here are some of the advantages of choosing a mixed-breed canine companion:


  • Health and Longevity: Mixed-breed dogs tend to be less likely to inherit genetic disorders common in certain purebred lines. This genetic diversity can contribute to better overall health and increased longevity. However, some studies show no statistical difference in the prevalence of genetic disorders between purebred and mixed-breed dogs.
  • Unique Traits: Each mixed breed dog is a one-of-a-kind combination of various breeds, resulting in a unique appearance, temperament, and set of characteristics. Even if you know what breeds are in the mix, knowing what physical or temperamental traits predominate will be challenging.
  • Adaptability: Due to their diverse genetic makeup, mixed-breed dogs often exhibit a more comprehensive range of traits, making them adaptable to various living environments and lifestyles. They’re known for being versatile and fitting in with different family dynamics.
  • Lower Cost: Compared to purchasing a purebred dog from a breeder, adopting a mixed breed dog from a shelter or rescue organization typically incurs lower costs. This makes it more accessible for individuals or families on a budget to experience the joys of pet ownership.
  • Reduced Behavioral Issues: By blending different breed traits, mixed breed dogs may be less prone to behavioral issues commonly associated with specific purebred lines.
  • Community Impact: By adopting a mixed-breed dog from a shelter or rescue, you’re gaining a loyal companion, reducing pet overpopulation, and supporting important animal welfare initiatives.


Purebred Dogs



Purebred dogs also offer unique benefits catering to dog owners’ specific preferences and requirements. The AKC says dedicated breeders monitor their dogs to eliminate the disease by removing afflicted dogs or carriers from their breeding program. 

For example, The Dog Genome Project allows researchers to study genes that result in disease; each year, breeders and veterinarians work together to eradicate the disease.

Here are some advantages of choosing a purebred puppy.


  • Predictable Characteristics: Purebred dogs are bred for specific traits, which can make it easier to predict their size, appearance, temperament, and energy level. This predictability can appeal to individuals with particular lifestyle or living situation needs.
  • Breed Standards: Each purebred dog is associated with a breed standard, which outlines the ideal characteristics and qualities of the breed. This standard can serve as a helpful guide for potential owners who have specific preferences for their pet’s appearance, behavior, and abilities.
  • Purpose-Bred Traits: Many purebred dogs were initially bred for specific purposes, such as herding, hunting, or providing companionship. This heritage and purpose-driven breeding can result in dogs with instinctual behaviors that align with their historical roles.
  • Community and Support: Purebred dog enthusiasts often form communities and clubs dedicated to specific breeds. This network can provide owners with valuable support, resources, and guidance, including access to breed-specific health information and training resources.
  • Performance and Competition: For those interested in dog sports, shows, or working activities, purebred dogs may excel due to their specialized breeding and predictable traits, making them well-suited for competitive events and specific tasks.
  • Preservation of Breeds: By choosing a purebred dog from a responsible breeder or pet counselor, you preserve specific breeds, helping maintain their historical lineage, characteristics, and genetic diversity.


Mixed Breed or Purebred Puppy: Which is Best for Your Lifestyle?

When considering a dog breed or mix that seamlessly integrates into your lifestyle, it is essential to evaluate your living situation, activity level, and preferences. 

You should focus on identifying qualities and traits that resonate with your lifestyle rather than solely considering the breed type. By evaluating factors such as activity level, size, grooming requirements, and temperament, you can find an excellent companion dog that fits seamlessly into your life, regardless of their lineage.


  • Active Lifestyle: If you lead an active lifestyle and enjoy outdoor adventures, consider breeds such as Australian Shepherds, Labrador Retrievers, or Border Collie mixes. Their high energy levels and intelligence make them great companions for hiking, running, and various outdoor activities.
  • City Living: Smaller breeds or mixes, such as Dachshunds, French Bulldogs, or Poodle mixes, can be ideal for people living in urban areas. Their adaptability to smaller living spaces and lower exercise requirements make them well-suited for city life.
  • Family-Friendly: Families seeking a loyal and gentle companion can consider breeds like Golden Retrievers, Beagles, or friendly mixed breeds from shelters. These breeds are known for their affectionate nature and compatibility with children, making them beautiful additions to family households.
  • Low-Activity Lifestyle: Individuals with a more relaxed lifestyle may find joy in the company of breeds like Shih Tzus, Cavalier King Charles Spaniels, or Chihuahua mixes. These breeds typically have lower exercise needs and can thrive in calmer environments.
  • Allergy Considerations: For those with allergy concerns, hypoallergenic breeds like Poodles, Bichon Frises, or mixes of these breeds may be suitable due to their minimal shedding and dander.
  • Companion for Seniors: Seniors looking for a mixed or purebred puppy do well with breeds like Maltese, Pomeranians, or puppies from shelters. Their smaller size, gentle temperament, and lower exercise requirements suit senior living well.


Uncertainty in Breed Mix Temperaments



Many vets and pet experts argue against choosing mixed breeds as pets. They express concerns about the uncertainty surrounding the blend of breeds in a mixed-breed puppy. 

This ambiguity can make it challenging to predict the dog’s adult size, potentially leading to unexpected challenges in housing and care. 

Consequently, there is a risk of ending up with a dog that does not fit your lifestyle, discovered only after you have already formed a bond with the animal. There will always be a chance that you end up with a dog that is unsuitable for you, but it’s too late because you’ve bonded with your pup already. 

On the other hand, though, there’s less of a chance of interbreeding. “They feel that mixed breeds are much less likely to exhibit the results of interbreeding, such as temperament,intelligence and health issues,” adds PetMD.




Predictable Traits in Purebred Puppies

Purebred pups offer several potential advantages for dog owners. Firstly, they often come with predictable traits, thanks to well-documented breed standards, which can provide insights into their potential size, temperament, grooming needs, and exercise requirements. Additionally, each purebred breed has unique characteristics and traits refined over generations, appealing to individuals with particular preferences. 

Reputable breeders often conduct health screenings on their purebred dogs, addressing potential genetic health issues and offering assurance about their pets’ long-term well-being. Furthermore, purebred dog owners can benefit from belonging to communities and clubs dedicated to specific breeds, which provide access to valuable resources, knowledge sharing, and support from fellow enthusiasts and experts. 

Many purebred dogs are purpose-bred for particular tasks or activities, excelling in these endeavors due to their specialized breeding and training. Lastly, supporting reputable purebred breeders contributes to preserving distinct dog breeds, ensuring that their unique traits and characteristics are maintained for future generations to appreciate and enjoy.


Final Thoughts



Understanding that breed alone does not determine the outcome, you can opt for a purebred or mixed breed and be happy. The best way to go about this is to research and have a good idea of what type of dog you want and whether the dog should be high-energy or low-energy.

When choosing a purebred or mixed-breed puppy, pet parents should weigh the advantages and considerations of each option. Purebred pups offer predictable traits, well-documented breed characteristics, health screenings, and the support of dedicated breed communities. On the other hand, mixed-breed puppies may exhibit hybrid vigor, unique combinations of traits, and potentially lower susceptibility to specific genetic health issues. 

Ultimately, the decision should be based on the prospective pet parent’s preferences, lifestyle, and needs. Regardless of the choice, responsible ownership, ethical breeding practices, and thoughtful consideration of the dog’s well-being are paramount. Both mixed and purebred puppies have advantages and disadvantages. The most important thing to remember is that how your puppy turns out depends on you.

“The puppy will still need to be disciplined and trained in order to grow into an intelligent and well-trained dog. Immediate obedience training and proper health care are essential for a well-balanced dog,” says PetMD.

Whether welcoming a purebred or mixed-breed puppy into the family, love, care, and commitment are essential in nurturing a happy and healthy puppy.


FAQ’s Purebred vs. Mixed Breed Puppies: Pros and Cons




Q: Is it better to get a purebred or mixed-breed?

A: “Buying from a breeder often means that the puppy comes with a “family plan,” a community of fellow breed owners. This community often delights to find each other and share the joys and challenges of owning their breed,” says the AKC. Some studies have indicated that purebred dogs may not be more prone to certain conditions like hip dysplasia than mixed breeds.

Q: “Why do people prefer purebred dogs?

A: Another significant factor influencing preferences is that purebred dogs are often perceived as healthier than mixed breeds due to their well-documented lineage and breed standards. 

Some pet parents also value the predictability of appearance, size, coat, and behavior that purebred dogs offer, which aligns with specific lifestyle preferences and expectations. 

The AKC states that “Parents can use their dog’s breed as a teaching tool and help their children learn about different cultures through the richness of the world’s dog breeds.”

Q: Do purebred dogs live longer?

A: Studies show that while gonadectomy is associated with increased lifespan in both males and females, “lower inbreeding and higher effective population size are associated with longer lifespans in purebred dogs.” 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *